---
title: IP Business Intelligence Blog | Patent Blog | Intellectual Property Blog | IP Blog | Patent Litigation (2)
description: Patent Litigation | Business perspectives on patents, strategy, innovation, entrepreneurship and technology by IPVision leaders, corporate executives, and MIT faculty. (2)
---

[![logo](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/hubfs/ipvision-site/images/logo.png?width=200&name=logo.png "logo")](http://www.ipvisioninc.com/)

- [Contact Us](http://www.ipvisioninc.com/about-us/contact-us/)
- [Blog](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions)

![IP vision blog banner](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/hubfs/ipvision-site/images/banner_blog-1.jpg?width=1400&name=banner_blog-1.jpg "IP vision blog banner")

## IPVision Blog

 Written by [Joseph Hadzima, Esq., Sr. Lecturer, MIT Sloan School of Management, President and Co-Founder of IPVision](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/author/joseph-hadzima-esq-sr-lecturer-mit-sloan-school-of-management-president-and-co-founder-of-ipvision)

## [Patent Maps of Paul Allen's Interval Research Lawsuit Patents](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/29479/patent-maps-of-paul-allen-s-interval-research-lawsuit-patents)

[![](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/file-2819120577-png/images/ipvision_landscape_map_of_4_paul_allen_lawsuit_patents.png) ](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/29479/patent-maps-of-paul-allen-s-interval-research-lawsuit-patents)

[The Wall Street Journal](http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704058704576015820206375808.html) reported on December 13, 2010 that U.S. District Judge Marsha Pechman in Seattle dismissed Paul Allen's patent lawsuit against many of the leading companies in Silicon Valley including Google, Apple, Facebook and Yahoo.  Judge Pechman dismissed the complaint for not describing its allegations specifically enough.   Paul Allen has until December 28 to amend the complaint.

[Read More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/29479/patent-maps-of-paul-allen-s-interval-research-lawsuit-patents)

 Categories: [Interval Research](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/interval-research), [Patent Landscape](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-landscape), [Patent Litigation](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)

[Comments (0) | Add a Comment](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/29479/patent-maps-of-paul-allen-s-interval-research-lawsuit-patents#comments-listing)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

 Written by [Joseph Hadzima, Esq., Sr. Lecturer, MIT Sloan School of Management, President and Co-Founder of IPVision](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/author/joseph-hadzima-esq-sr-lecturer-mit-sloan-school-of-management-president-and-co-founder-of-ipvision)

## [Patent Litigation Risk Continues to Increase - Gain Control](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/31760/patent-litigation-risk-continues-to-increase-gain-control)

A recent Wall Street Journal article discussed the recent multi-year increase in patent infringement lawsuits and [corporate risk](http://www.ipvisioninc.com/mitigate-corporate-risk/). Although this trend is most prevalent in the high-technology sector, economic and strategic realities are forcing corporate and outside counsel to find new methods to control the time and expense allocated to patent risk management.

[Read More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/31760/patent-litigation-risk-continues-to-increase-gain-control)

 Categories: [Patent Strategy](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-strategy), [Patent Analysis](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-analysis), [Patent Litigation](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)

[Comments (0) | Add a Comment](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/31760/patent-litigation-risk-continues-to-increase-gain-control#comments-listing)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

 Written by [Alex Butler](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/author/alex-butler)

## [Patent Litigation: Google Android Claimed to Infringe Java Patents](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/28675/Patent-Litigation-Google-Android-Claimed-to-Infringe-Java-Patents)

[![](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/file-2819119787-png/images/java_landscape_patent_map.png) ](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/28675/Patent-Litigation-Google-Android-Claimed-to-Infringe-Java-Patents)

On August 12, 2010, Oracle America, Inc. (Oracle) filed suit against Google, Inc. in the Northern District of California claiming that Google's Android operating system infringes 7 "Java" patents owned by Oracle America, a subsidiary of Oracle Corporation.   These Java patents are owned by Sun Microsystems which was acquired by Oracle in January 2010.

[Read More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/28675/Patent-Litigation-Google-Android-Claimed-to-Infringe-Java-Patents)

 Categories: [Patent Landscape](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-landscape), [Patent Analysis](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-analysis), [Patent Litigation](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)

[Comments (0) | Add a Comment](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/28675/Patent-Litigation-Google-Android-Claimed-to-Infringe-Java-Patents#comments-listing)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

 Written by [Joseph Hadzima, Esq., Sr. Lecturer, MIT Sloan School of Management, President and Co-Founder of IPVision](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/author/joseph-hadzima-esq-sr-lecturer-mit-sloan-school-of-management-president-and-co-founder-of-ipvision)

## [M86 Patent Litigation Against Leading Internet Security Firms](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/26641/M86-Patent-Litigation-Against-Leading-Internet-Security-Firms)

[![](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/file-2839897645-png/images/hostile_downloadables_patent_map.png) ](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/26641/M86-Patent-Litigation-Against-Leading-Internet-Security-Firms)

[M86Security](http://www.m86security.com/) has filed a patent lawsuit in Delaware against McAfee, Symantec, Webroot Software, Websense and Sophos alledging infringement of two "hostile downloadables" patents owned by Finjan Software. Representing M86Security is [Philip A. Rovner](http://www.potteranderson.com/attorneys-32.html) of Potter Anderson and Corroon LLP and [Paul J. Andre](http://www.kslaw.com/bio/Paul_Andre) of King and Spaulding.   [Finjan was acquired by M86Security in November 2009](http://www.finjan.com/Pressrelease.aspx?id=2388&PressLan=2139&lan=3).  M86Security describes itself as "... the largest provider of Secure Web Gateways and the largest independent provider of Web and e-mail content security in the world. Four leading technology companies have merged to become a full-service, single source provider of Web and e-mail gateway security, encryption and DLP solutions."  

[Read More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/26641/M86-Patent-Litigation-Against-Leading-Internet-Security-Firms)

 Categories: [Technology Review](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/technology-review), [Patent Litigation](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)

[Comments (0) | Add a Comment](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/26641/M86-Patent-Litigation-Against-Leading-Internet-Security-Firms#comments-listing)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

 Written by [Alex Butler](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/author/alex-butler)

## [Patent Litigation Drives VirnetX Stock](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/24850/Patent-Litigation-Drives-VirnetX-Stock)

[![](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/file-2839896890-png/images/virnetx1.png) ](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/24850/Patent-Litigation-Drives-VirnetX-Stock)

Fresh from a post about the 9-digit [VirnetX Microsoft patent litigation settlement](http://web.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/23471/Patent-Litigation-Settled-Microsoft-Pays-200M-to-VirnetX) by IPVision executive and Sloan School of Management faculty member Joe Hadzima, [VirnetX announced](http://www.marketwatch.com/story/virnetx-advances-to-russell-3000-index-and-global-index-2010-06-15?reflink=MW_news_stmp) that they are moving from microcap status to inclusion in the broader Russell 3000 index. In addition, VirnetX is issuing a special dividend of $.50 per share for shareholders of record on July 1.

[Read More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/24850/Patent-Litigation-Drives-VirnetX-Stock)

 Categories: [Patent Strategy](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-strategy), [Patent Analysis](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-analysis), [Patent Litigation](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)

[Comments (0) | Add a Comment](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/24850/Patent-Litigation-Drives-VirnetX-Stock#comments-listing)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

 Written by [Alex Butler](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/author/alex-butler)

## [What does (should) Patent Landscape Analysis Mean to Business Leaders?](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/21985/what-does-should-patent-landscape-analysis-mean-to-business-leaders)

[![](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/file-2810665251-jpg/images/tech1.jpg) ](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/21985/what-does-should-patent-landscape-analysis-mean-to-business-leaders)

The phrase "[patent landscape](http://www.ipvisioninc.com/technology-landscape/)" has become quite popular amongst the patent specialists and patent expert set. Their gravitation to the term is well-founded given the [importance of IP rights to corporate success](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/company/ipvision-news--updates/ip-in-early-stage-commercial---investment-success/).

[Read More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/21985/what-does-should-patent-landscape-analysis-mean-to-business-leaders)

 Categories: [Patent Landscape](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-landscape), [Patent Strategy](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-strategy), [Patent Analysis](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-analysis), [Patent Litigation](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)

[Comments (0) | Add a Comment](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/ipvisions/bid/21985/what-does-should-patent-landscape-analysis-mean-to-business-leaders#comments-listing)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

 Written by [Alex Butler](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/author/alex-butler)

## [Patent Risk Management and Controlling Patent Litigation Costs](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/21987/Patent-Risk-Management-and-Controlling-Patent-Litigation-Costs)

[![](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/file-2839894740-png/images/litigation_response_game_theory1.png) ](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/21987/Patent-Risk-Management-and-Controlling-Patent-Litigation-Costs)

Patent risk profiles of corporations have dramatically shifted given two recent patent litigation dynamics:

1. The rise of patent trolls or NPE's (non-practicing entities)
2. The decline of patent infringement 'notice' letters replaced by direct filing of patent complaints 

The first dynamic is economic and includes a range of strategic and financial investors, including for example the well-known [Intellectual Ventures](http://intven.com/), and others such as [Juridica](http://www.juridica.co.uk/) and [Altititude Capital](http://www.altitudecp.com/). These investors and an increasing number of firms see opportunities in the exclusionary rights provided by patents to obtain high-risk / high-reward economic returns.

The second dynamic is legal - driven by court decisions that incent patent plaintiffs to file first and negotiate second (the reverse of historical tendencies). 

[Read More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/21987/Patent-Risk-Management-and-Controlling-Patent-Litigation-Costs)

 Categories: [Patent Strategy](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-strategy), [Patent Analysis](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-analysis), [Patent Litigation](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)

[Comments (0) | Add a Comment](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/21987/Patent-Risk-Management-and-Controlling-Patent-Litigation-Costs#comments-listing)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

 Written by [Joseph Hadzima, Esq., Sr. Lecturer, MIT Sloan School of Management, President and Co-Founder of IPVision](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/author/joseph-hadzima-esq-sr-lecturer-mit-sloan-school-of-management-president-and-co-founder-of-ipvision)

## [Patent Litigation Settled: Microsoft Pays $200M to VirnetX](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/23471/Patent-Litigation-Settled-Microsoft-Pays-200M-to-VirnetX)

[![](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/file-2839895990-png/images/2_virnetx_patents2.png) ](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/23471/Patent-Litigation-Settled-Microsoft-Pays-200M-to-VirnetX)

Ellen Rosen of [Bloomberg Businessweek](http://www.businessweek.com/news/2010-05-18/microsoft-hyundai-cable-tv-intellectual-property-update1-.html) reported today that Microsoft paid $200 million to settle patent litigation brought by [VirnetX Holdings Corporation](http://www.virnetx.com/index.php) in February 2007.   VirnetX alleged that Microsoft infringed two VirnetX U.S. patents that covered the Virtual Private Network (VPN) technology contained in Microsoft Windows and Officer Server products. 

[Read More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/23471/Patent-Litigation-Settled-Microsoft-Pays-200M-to-VirnetX)

 Categories: [Patent Landscape](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-landscape), [Patent Strategy](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-strategy), [Patent Litigation](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)

[Comments (0) | Add a Comment](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/IPVisions/bid/23471/Patent-Litigation-Settled-Microsoft-Pays-200M-to-VirnetX#comments-listing)

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

Load More

### Follow IPVision

- [**](https://www.linkedin.com/company/381481?trk=tyah&trkInfo=clickedVertical%3Acompany%2CclickedEntityId%3A381481%2Cidx%3A2-4-5%2CtarId%3A1457382100602%2Ctas%3Aipvision)
- [**](https://twitter.com/ipvisioninc)

### Subscribe via Email

![landscape-map.png](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/hs-fs/hubfs/ipvision-site/images/landscape-map.png?width=103&name=landscape-map.png "landscape-map.png")

### Create a patent landscape map

Patent citation analysis that makes it simple to explore complex relationships with a visual guide

[Learn More](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/view-patent-landscape-map)

### Categories

- [Acquisition Programs (4)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/acquisition-programs)
- [Advantage Dashboard (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/advantage-dashboard)
- [Boards of Directors (9)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/boards-of-directors)
- [Corporate Venture (4)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/corporate-venture)
- [COVID-19 (8)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/covid-19)
- [Disruptive Innovation (13)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/disruptive-innovation)
- [Entrepreneurship (2)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/entrepreneurship)
- [Industry Study (2)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/industry-study)
- [Innovation (27)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/innovation)
- [Intellectual Ventures (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/intellectual-ventures)
- [Interval Research (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/interval-research)
- [IP Innovation (11)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ip-innovation)
- [IP Investment (6)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ip-investment)
- [IP Management (8)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ip-management)
- [IP Monetization (9)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ip-monetization)
- [IP Research (6)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ip-research)
- [IPO (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ipo)
- [IPVision News (13)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ipvision-news)
- [IPVision Update (9)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ipvision-update)
- [IV (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/iv)
- [Lemelson-MIT Program (15)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/lemelson-mit-program)
- [M&A (16)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/ma)
- [MIT (7)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/mit)
- [National Science Foundation (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/national-science-foundation)
- [Patent Analysis (59)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-analysis)
- [Patent Assertion Entities (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-assertion-entities)
- [Patent Benchmarks (4)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-benchmarks)
- [patent claims analysis (5)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-claims-analysis)
- [Patent Context (3)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-context)
- [Patent Cost (10)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-cost)
- [Patent Landscape (42)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-landscape)
- [Patent Litigation (18)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-litigation)
- [Patent Management Process (5)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-management-process)
- [Patent News (48)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-news)
- [Patent Pending (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-pending)
- [Patent Review Committee (4)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-review-committee)
- [Patent Rosetta Stone (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-rosetta-stone)
- [Patent Search (2)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-search)
- [Patent Software (2)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-software)
- [Patent Strategy (50)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-strategy)
- [Patent Trafficking (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patent-trafficking)
- [Patents (8)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/patents)
- [R&D (7)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/rd)
- [Research-in-Motion (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/research-in-motion)
- [Smart Technologies (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/smart-technologies)
- [Supreme Court (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/supreme-court)
- [Technology Commercialzation (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/technology-commercialzation)
- [Technology Landscape (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/technology-landscape)
- [Technology Review (2)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/technology-review)
- [Technology Transfer (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/technology-transfer)
- [Time Horizons (1)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/time-horizons)
- [US Patent System (4)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/us-patent-system)
- [Venture Capital (6)](https://info.ipvisioninc.com/blog/topic/venture-capital)

### Recent Posts

###### IPVision, Inc. 

 800 South Street, Suite 350  
Waltham, MA 02453  
P 1 (617) 475-6000 F 1 (617) 475-6001   
E [info@ipvisioninc.com](mailto:info@ipvisioninc.com)

Copyright 2021 IPVision, Inc. All Rights Reserved.    
[Privacy Policy](http://www.ipvisioninc.com/privacy-policy/) | [Terms of Use ](http://www.ipvisioninc.com/terms-of-use/)  
Website designed and developed by   
[RainCastle Communications, Inc.](http://www.raincastle.com/industry-consulting-professional-services/)

- [**](https://www.linkedin.com/company/381481?trk=tyah&trkInfo=clickedVertical%3Acompany%2CclickedEntityId%3A381481%2Cidx%3A2-4-5%2CtarId%3A1457382100602%2Ctas%3Aipvision)
- [**](https://twitter.com/ipvisioninc)

![](https://googleads.g.doubleclick.net/pagead/viewthroughconversion/923613572/?value=0&guid=ON&script=0)